The Earl of Chesterfield, on 13 May 2025 - 03:44 PM, said:
Starmer is wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong.
You don't beat Reform by being an even worse version of them - you beat Reform by being a better version of Labour.
Restore the WFA. Or at least raise the threshold so only the truly well off lose it.
Restore benefit payments to the most vulnerable in society. In fact go further and remove the two child cap.
Restore Border Force and the immigration system to levels capable of reducing the scandalous backlog created by the Badenoch and Jenrick conveniently suffering severe cases of amnesia regarding their record.
Restore safe and legal routes rendering the human traffickers redundant.
Restore international agreements such as the Dublin Accord which obliged other countries to accept removals.
Then confront the myths, misinformation and mindless tropes being peddled by Reform head on.
Point out that with an ageing population and falling birthrate the UK needs migrant workers to do the jobs to pay the taxes to fund the pensions.
Point out that our NHS would collapse overnight without them.
Point out that not just the care sector, but pretty much every other would quickly follow too.
All whilst embracing Labour's historical allies the trade unions to ensure pay and employment practices attract more British born applicants.
Point out it's decades of social housing sold off without replacement that's created homelessness.
Point out it's decades of underfunding that's created disgraceful waiting lists.
Starmer could also point out how many millions foreign students contribute towards universities or the 'Staff Wanted' signs in countless windows following the Brexit supposed, of course, to 'take back control' of all this.
Only for migration to rise from around two hundred thousand to nearly a million under Boris Johnson.
That's Boris Johnson.
However rather than do any of that he chose to further facilitate the Farage led feeding frenzy.
To pander to prejudice.
To parrot none other than Enoch Powell.
I don't know from which demographic he's seeking support, but I do know I'm not a member...
a lot of very important reality in there Chris. you never beat an idiot by getting down to their level, they beat you with experience!
we do need migrant workers - care, building and construction, health, hospitality, food. UK workers dont want the jobs - but its not pay and conditions, its a combination of factors - benefits culture, cash in hand work, they dont like hard work, etc etc. Min Wage is now effectively £25k a year full time equivalent... childcare costs and nursery costs are probably an issue too - but the proportion of earnings being saved (at 12% overall) is as high as its been for a long time. households are shoring up their personal balance sheets and not spending because of all of the uncertainty in the world.
one of the highest ranked risks in the world this year is around information and misinformation. Starmer wont resolve that on his own so he is going to have to trust the process, take decisions that work long term and accept short term drop in popularity. its what politicians used to do...
He cant introduce a WFA with a higher cap as the costs of administering would be higher than the saving and so it would look like spite...
But his real problem is growth. It might be 1% this year or less if they raise taxes in the next budget - and to not raise taxes they will need to fudge the numbers (source chief economist at a major professional services firm). they cant build the houses because we dont have the skilled people. Same applies to public sector capital projects that dont have the skilled resource and also the public sector moves at a glacial pace on these things =- dont think they have heard of agile project management.
But if he can force through some growth, not raise taxes, hope the orange idiot doesnt start throwing economic grenades again, and stick to what he believes is right for the country, he may ride out the storm to better days (rougher seas!). The problem is he doest have beliefs underpinning policy and he flip flops with the wind...
Stay Home. Stay Safe.